Chapter III: What IS the connection between productivity, turnover and job match?

A study published by Harvard Business Review indicated that normal ‘performance indicators’ (education, experience, sex, gender, race, age) are NOT what cause a person to fit their job and become a superior performer with an increase in productivity and a decrease in turnover.

The study (360,000 employees over 20 years in 14 industries) concluded the factors that cause a person to fit their job are how well the respective person matches the needs of each job with regards to: mental capabilities, behavioral traits and occupational interests.

As we all know, success in any job is related to how well the person does the job.

However, the measurement of success in any job (sales volume and/or profit are commonly used measures along with inventory value, orders filled completely, etc) does not tell us WHY someone was successful or not, they just tell us IF the person was successful or not.

How well any person does in any job is DIRECTLY related to the learning skills required by the job, the behavior necessary in that organization, and the interests needed to stick with the job COMPARED to the capability of the respective employee.

In most companies, top performers have more productivity (at least 60%) and less turnover (up to 300% less) than average workers. Thus the connection between Job Fit and productivity and turnover is clear: the better the job fit, the higher the productivity and the lower the turnover.

Since top performers capabilities CAN be measured with regards to learning, behavior and interests in any job, a job pattern can be established that indicates what the job requires. Once the pattern is established (every job in every company is UNIQUE), potential candidates (or struggling incumbents) can be compared to the pattern to determine job match.

If a high job match is present, productivity goes up and turnover goes down because the employees LITERALLY fit their jobs.

If a low job match is present, productivity goes down and turnover goes up because employees can’t do the job (mental), can’t do the job the right way (behavior), or won’t do the job (lack of interest).

Unfortunately, an interview is the most common hiring process toda, which finds a top performer less than 15% of the time. In other words, the process fails to find the top performer you are looking for more than 85% of the time. Talk about a dysfunctional process!

If you are coming to St. Louis for NAMA National in mid October, I would recommend you plan to check out the HOT TOPIC presentations that are presented during show hours at the main NAMA both. You can be face to face with experts that CAN help your business, and ask them the questions you always want to ask….but never have the chance.

Coming next quarter: How your hirning process impacts your bottom line!

“See you in St. Louis, Louis”…..travel safe!

Sincerely,

Dave McCaffrey

Biography of Dave McCaffrey:

Before becoming a strategic partner of Profiles International™, Dave McCaffrey built a thirty year career in the fast food, convenience store, vending, and Office Coffee Service segments, ultimately holding senior segment management positions at Oscar Mayer, Kraft Foods, and Starbucks Coffee Company.

Over his career, he developed successful relationships with corporate clients such as ARAMARK, Compass Group, Circle K, 7-Eleven and Standard Coffee Service Company, as well as many regional and local independent businesses in the foodservice industry. Dave also grew and enjoyed productive relationships with brokerage and distributive components, as well as segment specific media and national associations of each unique foodservice segment.

Dave feels his greatest professional (and personal) accomplishment of his successful corporate career was the fact that many of the people that he managed were able to move up to their own managerial responsibility. His own management experience gave him the understanding of the benefit of accurate personnel assessments as quality tools for developing key employee engagement and effectiveness.

Having received his Bachelor of Science degree from the University of Wisconsin, he also earned an Associate Degree in Marketing from the Madison Area Community College.

Actively involved in many volunteer capacities, Dave is a member of several commissions at Immaculate Conception Parish (Elmhurst, IL) In addition, Dave and his wife Rita actively mentor engaged couples participating in the Joliet (IL) Diocese pre-marriage program.

Dave and his wife Rita (Flad), both from Madison WI, have been married for forty+ years (’67), and have lived in Elmhurst, Illinois, for over ten years. They have two daughters, both of whom live and work in the Chicago area.

Leave a Reply