Are your top performers ‘looking around’?

According to a new study by Leadership IQ, 47% of high performers are actively looking for other jobs (they’re posting and submitting resumes, and even going on interviews).  

While it’s terrible that almost half of high performers are thinking about quitting, what’s perhaps even worse is that low performers want to stay.  Only 18% of low performing employees are actively seeking other jobs, and 25% of middle performers are actively looking around.  (DHM note: why would they be seeking other jobs; they’ve found a home! They have figured out how to stay below the radar and collect a check for minimal contribution.  How long can you afford non revenue producing employees that usually make up 80% of your total workforce?). 

 Leadership IQ surveyed 16,237 employees on a range of workforce and retention issues, and then divided them into high, middle and low performer categories based on their annual performance appraisal scores.  There were 3,896 employees identified as high performers, 8,607 identified as middle performers, and 3,734 low performers. “High performers keep companies in business,” says Mark Murphy, CEO of Leadership IQ, “so every company is at risk if these people leave.  If you lose some low performers, you might actually be better off.  But when your best people quit, revenue drops, quality suffers, and snafus increase.  Even large companies can take a big hit with the departure of just a few key employees.” 

Murphy continues “The worst part of this is that we typically cause our high performers to quit by how we treat them.  Frankly, we treat our high performers worse than any other employee.  When a manager has a tough project upon which the whole company depends, to whom do they turn?  Who gets the late hours and the stress?  It’s not the low performers, because managers want the project done right.  Instead managers turn to their handful of high performers.  Over and over we ask our high performers to go above and beyond, making their jobs tough and burning them out at a terrible pace.  Meanwhile, low performers often get easier jobs because their bosses dread dealing with them and may avoid them altogether.”

So what can you do to keep your top performers happy?  Make sure you know WHY they are your top performers, not just that they are….because of sales or collections or new business. 

If you understand WHY your top performers do what they do, you can improve performance of your middle and lower groups, reducing strain on top performers while improving profitability and reducing turnover. 

The old adage…..”you cannot manage what you cannot measure”….has never been so true as it is when talking about improving performance.  There ARE tools available to help you make sure you retain your top performers and improve the rest of your team at costs FAR less than replacing a top performer…or paying a full salary to a low performer that is a non-revenue expense. 

Your employees are your company’s single most important asset: are you investing in them as much as your other assets?  If you want to be around tomorrow, investing in employees today is a good bet!

Biography of Dave McCaffrey:

Before becoming a strategic partner of Profiles International™, Dave McCaffrey built a thirty year career in the fast food, convenience store, vending, and Office Coffee Service segments, ultimately holding senior segment management positions at Oscar Mayer, Kraft Foods, and Starbucks Coffee Company.

Over his career, he developed successful relationships with corporate clients such as ARAMARK, Compass Group, Circle K, 7-Eleven and Standard Coffee Service Company, as well as many regional and local independent businesses in the foodservice industry. Dave also grew and enjoyed productive relationships with brokerage and distributive components, as well as segment specific media and national associations of each unique foodservice segment.

Dave feels his greatest professional (and personal) accomplishment of his successful corporate career was the fact that many of the people that he managed were able to move up to their own managerial responsibility. His own management experience gave him the understanding of the benefit of accurate personnel assessments as quality tools for developing key employee engagement and effectiveness.

Having received his Bachelor of Science degree from the University of Wisconsin, he also earned an Associate Degree in Marketing from the Madison Area Community College.

Actively involved in many volunteer capacities, Dave is a member of several commissions at Immaculate Conception Parish (Elmhurst, IL) In addition, Dave and his wife Rita actively mentor engaged couples participating in the Joliet (IL) Diocese pre-marriage program.

Dave and his wife Rita (Flad), both from Madison WI, have been married for forty+ years (’67), and have lived in Elmhurst, Illinois, for over ten years. They have two daughters, both of whom live and work in the Chicago area.

3 Responses to “Are your top performers ‘looking around’?”

  1. elmhurst il Says:

    […] is a member of several commissions at Immaculate Conception Parish Elmhurst, IL In addition, …http://www.amonline.com/blog/2008/07/30/are-your-top-performers-looking-around/BREAKING NEWS: No tornado touches down in Elmhurst Elmhurst Argus Press Spectator Despite reports, […]

  2. Employee Retention Says:

    It was probably so hard for the low performers to actually find a job… why would they ever want to quit?

  3. Dave McCaffrey Says:

    To Employee Retention re Top Performers and “It was probably so hard for the low performers to actually find a job… why would they ever want to quit?”

    Thanks….my point exactly…..they will never want to quit…but the 20% of your performers may get tired of generating 80% of the revenue for your company and seek a place that does not ‘mis-treat’ them.

    Much better solution is to identify low producers and replace them with top producers. No business can afford to have non-productive employees.

    Hope everyone has a great day!

    Dave

Leave a Reply